Become a Great Transit/Paratransit Company
Building and maintaining a winning team
Great transit/paratransit companies hire, nurture and retain great people. They build cohesive teams around a shared vision. It takes dozens of integrated processes to achieve greatness. Most of these processes are focused on people: recruiting, selection and hiring, orientation, education and training, performance support and leadership. These strategies form the foundation for acquiring, building and maintaining a great team.
This paper challenges you to rise above the sea of mediocre competitors and become a great transit/paratransit company. The path is long and the journey is difficult, but the rewards are life-changing. Great companies grow, prosper and make more money than their lesser competitors.
But the business outcomes of creating a great company pale in comparison to the personal satisfaction you can derive from all the extra effort. Happiness evolves from a life well-lived –giving back to society, helping others and being the best you can be. Creating something great leads to self-actualization.
There are things you can do right now…today…to get started on your path to greatness. They begin with your people and your people processes. Some changes are inexpensive and some aren’t. Some are easy, while others require more thoughtful planning and tenacious execution. Some will help a little and some will help significantly.
Most importantly, the strategies are synergistic. Each one provides value, but when combined, the results are remarkable. In fact, the sum is far greater than the parts. The key is to get started with new processes that can help.
Great leadership begins with self-awareness. Who are you? What do you stand for? What do you want to achieve? That awareness applies to your business as well. What markets do you serve? What image do you want your organization to project? By carefully analyzing and fully understanding who you really are, you can determine who best fits your team.
This paper delves into the transformative people processes necessary to achieve greatness in the transit/paratransit industry. It is not a path for everyone to take. After all, not everyone can be great.
It’s All About Winning
When you start your business with that first bus or van, it’s not about winning, it’s about survival. There are so many things that you don’t know and most of them can hurt you. But after some hardships, some struggles, some misplaced enthusiasm and some happy customers, the business, still fragile, begins to grow. Bigger and better things are on the horizon.
At first… it’s not about winning, it’s about survival
Time passes quickly. You’re no longer in a survival mode, although set-backs and harsh realities occassionally bring survival back into your consciousness. Soon, your thoughts turn to growth. If you’ve been lucky enough and skillful enough to surround yourself with a few good people, you have some help for your journey. At first, everyone pitches in to do everything and no one minds. Routing, accounting, marketing, washing buses, cooking hamburgers at lunch, emptying the waste baskets…you and your staff do it all.
But one day you look around and the business has grown exponentionaly, and you and your small team no longer have all the answers. Your jack-of-all-trades fellowship has holes. You need specialists to take the business to the next level. So you hire some computer tekkies and marketing types to improve your web site and who know terms like SEO and meta-tags. You retain transit engineering and dispatch consultants. You hire a certifited System Status Management expert. Perhaps you are already this far along.
And then you wake up one morning and realize that just having a good business it not good enough; you want to have a great business. One that can be passed on to the next generation. One that won’t get stomped out during the next economic downturn. One that does things so well it can compete head-on with the best of the best. But how do you go from good to great?
The opening line of Jim Collins landmark book, Good To Great, tells it all: “Good is the enemy of great.” He quickly builds on this concept by noting that we mostly have good schools, good government and a good life. But things that are great are rare indeed. Perhaps you have a good company. And that might be your greatest challenge.
Good is the enemy of great.
Business is all about winning. Beating your competition. Great companies win. Weak companies lose. And the ones in the middle (the good guys) plod along. Do you have what it takes to become great? Do you even want to be great? Anyone can have a vision, but very few are able to execute the people processes needed to actually achieve greatness.
What Makes You So Special?
You undoubtedly have great pride in your company and its heritage. So, if someone challenges you, asking that schoolyard taunt, “what makes you so special?,” you immediately bristle. As a business owner, I would too. It’s second nature. We’re quick to defend our family, our tribe, our nation and our company.
But the question lingers, what does make you so special? What sets you apart from other transit/paratransit companies? You’re in a competitive market, but the competition isn’t only over municipal contracts, it’s mostly over employees. You’re in a fierce battle to attract, hire and retain high quality employees. And the employees who are looking for a job want to know one thing: what makes you so special?
Chances are good that they’ve worked for two or three other companies or agencies already who all claimed to be “special.” They all promised respect and a host of other platitudes. But they didn’t deliver and that’s why the industry is plagued with 75% turnover and the common belief that there is an operator shortage.
You can whine and moan about your challenges. You can claim you’re in a tough business and it’s hard to find good people. But, you don’t have a monopoly on the difficult challenge of finding people to work in a tough environment for low wages. Try retail, where pay is rarely more than minimum wage, the work takes place in the evening or on weekends when your friends are all off having fun. An industry where turnover is often in excess of 200%. How do retailers survive? Better yet, how does one particular retailer grow at a rate of 20% year after year for 32 years in a row?
You don’t have the monopoly on difficult staffing challenges.
That retailer is the privately owned Container Store, out of Dallas, Texas. It outperforms all other retailers in revenue-per-square-foot by a factor of 500% and, coincidentally, it’s made Fortune’s list of 100 Best Places to Work in America in each of the past 11 years. Most analysts would describe this company as great. Perhaps there are lessons to be learned.
Let’s dig a little deeper to find out why…
Their self-described key to success: PEOPLE.
It begins with a devotion to recruiting, hiring, training and retaining a highly qualified workforce and providing a unique culture, based on their six founding principles. They only hire great people (3% of applicants), as defined, in part, by these key attributes:
Love of People
Peer to Customer
They insist that just one great employee outperforms three average employees! And, they’re willing to leave a slot open until they can find the next great team member. Compare that to their competitors who hire just about anyone who completes an application.
Their employee referral program is so effective that across the entire country they went eight months last year without placing a single help wanted ad. What do you pay for advertising?
Hiring great people is just the first step to achieving amazing results at the Container Store. Each new employee is assigned a personal mentor and everyone gets more than 240 hours of first-year training, compared to an industry average of 10 hours. Is it expensive? You bet. Does it pay off? Just look at those performance numbers again. Five-to-one greater sales per square foot and 32 continuous years of 20% growth! Wow. Maybe high quality training makes a difference.
So you can sit back and accept 75% employee turnover and blame it on the industry. And, you can keep shelling out $2,500 per month and roll the dice on marginal recruiting ads, trying to put people in empty seats. Or, you can try something different. It begins by understanding what makes you special.
If you can actually define what makes you special, you can begin to attract great employees who like what you have to offer. All too often, recruiting ads feature an employee saying nice things about their employer. These are based on the advertising designs of the early 1960s and rely on the I can relate to that philosophy. That is, people will more readily believe someone who is a peer. In today’s jargon, someone in their social network.
Attract employees who like what you have to offer.
Your recruiting and advertising messages should focus on what makes you so special – what makes you different. They have to be appealing and catchy to get everyone’s attention. But most importantly, your recruiting program needs to captivate the applicants who are a best-fit for you, the people who would love to work at a company like yours.
The tragic effects of high employee turnover hurt just about everyone, but just imagine the competitive advantage you would have by cutting your turnover in half. Suddenly, the enormous financial burden that plagues your lesser competitors becomes a remarkable opportunity for you. While they burn through cash paying for churn, you can be buying more buses and winning more contracts. Winning begins with selecting and hiring winners. Start there.
The Big Wet Kiss
Think back to your dating days…the budding days of a new romance. What happened first. Did your date make you sign the rule book or take a drug test? If so, you probably ran away like your hair was on fire. Chances are pretty good that you spent quality time together, getting to know more about each other. Getting to know his or her likes and dislikes and, most importantly, values. In our personal life, it’s called falling in love. In a job setting, it’s called alignment.
Your first and best opportunity to achieve alignment is during the initial orientation and onboarding process. Although the process of alignment never really ends, it’s doomed to fail if it doesn’t begin at the beginning. New employees are apprehensive. They just made a big decision to join you. They have legitimate concerns about how they’ll be treated and what will be expected of them.
Acclimating the new employee to your culture is vital to his or her commitment and longevity. But orientation is far too often a mismatched bunch of activities that convolute selection, onboarding and alignment into one fast-paced whirlwind of activity, followed by an almost complete disengagement, as the new employee is given his keys and sent on his way.
Alignment is vital to longevity.
For example, most companies give employees physicals and drug tests after an offer, as a condition of employment, making it a quasi-part of the orientation process. It doesn’t take much to realize that these things are part of selection, not orientation.
Further, the recruits spend a lot of the time completing paperwork, choosing benefit options, signing legal forms or going over the rules (onboarding).
While these activities are important, even required, they aren’t orienting or aligning anyone. In fact, they plant damaging seeds. They create an impression of red-tape and bureaucracy. That’s not who you really are, so why lead them to think that?
Why not separate those last few steps of selection (e.g. tests and physicals) from the onboarding activities (e.g. completing company paperwork). Then provide a real orientation process, one that welcomes the new employee to your company family and explains your culture. Tell her how happy you are to have her on the team. Tell her how she can expect to be treated. Explain what you will expect from her.
Make no mistake; initial employee orientation has a huge impact on first year retention levels. Do it right and enjoy the benefits of lower turnover and better overall job performance.
Heavy Weights, Light Weights and Waits
Although effective selection, hiring and orientation are all vital, they are by no means the only people-processes necessary to achieve better employee retention. There are lots of reasons for turnover, too numerous to list here. In fact, through our research we’ve assembled a list of 192 different reasons why an operator might decide to leave you only to land at another company –and one with a poor reputation to boot.
A handy way of looking at the root causes for employee turnover is using the metaphor of weights-on-a scale.
There are positives for joining and staying with your company and there are negatives. Every one of your employees joined your company because, at the time of hire, the positives seemed to outweigh the negatives.
Once on board, the scale continues to evolve. Weights are added or removed. Some are positive and some negative. As long as the positives outweigh or balance the negatives, the employee stays. However, if at any point the negatives outweigh the positives, the likelihood for turnover increases.
Different events in the employee’s life have different weights. Some mean a lot more than others. More importantly, some are real and some are imagined. Facts versus fiction. But in the employee’s mind, negative fiction weighs just as much as hard reality. Psychologists describe this phenomenon as perception is reality.
The scale appears to be stacked against you and maybe it is.
Common events such as lengthy waits to pick up a paratransit passenger, or “getting stuck” driving the paddle that always has the most traffic delays are often interpreted by the employee as avoidable. Worse, negative events tend to be personalized. Why did they give me this route? They don’t care about me. They lied to me. And so it goes, real or imagined, the negative red bricks add up and the teeter totter tips. There goes another one.
The dispatcher, who is legitimately too busy to answer an employee’s question, drops the same big red brick on the scale as the dispatcher who just doesn’t care. In the eyes of the employee, both encounters are negative. Efficiency is vital, but it’s only a piece of the puzzle. Interpersonal skills are needed, but on their own, are not enough. Caring is also important, but without efficiency and interpersonal skills, it too falls short.
That means your managers and supervisors have to be efficient, skilled and caring to avoid tipping the scales. On the other hand, positives are only positive if the employee is actually aware of them. The plusses don’t do you any good, unless you promote them.
Employees don’t leave great companies. But, they often leave good ones.
Consider the word churn. Churn doesn’t just mean turnover. It means employees moving between companies who all provide comparable working conditions. The employee doesn’t change jobs and get a $20,000 raise, different working conditions or a brand new bus. He didn’t improve himself, or even his situation for that matter. He just finds himself in at a different company or agency with a different logo and eventually comes to believe that everyone’s the same. Maybe he’s right. Maybe everyone is good, but they sure aren’t great.
Why Would They Ever Leave?
When NBA players get called for too many fouls, they ascribe it to lack of respect. Even if their hammering drew an opponent’s blood, they believe the referee doesn’t appreciate their skills. You would never call that on LeBron or Kobe! This respect theme is pervasive among transit and paratransit employees.
A poor pay package is interpreted as a lack of respect. Delays in getting paid are just like being dissed. Not getting good shifts or prime routes are both seen as a lack of respect. Always driving the bus with the quirky heater? No doubt about it. Bad.
In fact, it’s difficult to imagine any negative circumstance, real or perceived, that isn’t interpreted by an employee as a lack of respect.
Any negative event is seen as disrespect
Do your employees bear the brunt of inefficient system status management procedures or good old fashioned mistakes? Are they routinely forced to work overtime with little or no advanced notice? Are they forced to deal with automated answering machines, “press 9 for dispatch…” or wait on hold forever, just to talk to a human being? These are all big red bricks on the employee’s scales of justice. Real or imagined, they begin to add up and eventually lead to a tipping point.
Our research identified 192 specific reasons why an employee might leave one company and go to another, but it wasn’t easy to get operators to articulate this level of detail. When asked why they left, most operators resort to very broad explanations, such as: They lied to me. They didn’t show me any respect. They broke a promise. They treated me badly. They didn’t care about me.
But what really happened in these situations? Were they really lies, or did something go wrong that forced the dispatcher to make a decision that caused the operator to interpret the event as a lie?
You can’t fix the problem until you can accurately define it.
Einstein once said that 90% of solving a problem was accurately defining it. And that’s true for employee turnover. You can’t possibly solve such broadly stated problems as disrespect or lies. You have to dig down to the micro-level and, one-by-one, identify and eliminate those discrete 192 reasons that are stacking up the red bricks.
Employees want to feel appreciated. They want to be a contributing member of a winning team. They want to have a purpose and clear goals. They want to know if they’re doing a good job and, if not, what they can do to perform better. They want someone to talk to once in a while; someone to listen and maybe even solve a problem or two along the way.
Great companies have great employees and they know how to keep those great employees happy. It doesn’t cost any more than treating them like cattle. Strip away those big red bricks and be sure to self-promote the green ones.
Employees leave for many reasons, but the vast majority of those reasons are easily remedied. Tip the scales in your favor and become a great company.
Plug the Leaks
It’s amazing how often good companies discuss their problems but fail to study and measure their underlying causes. Employee turnover is one of the best examples. The entire industry wrings its collective hands and bemoans the situation as a curse that all must bear. Remarkably, the preferred strategy seems to be recruiting. Let’s find some more operators and put some people into these empty seats. Why not systematically plug the leaks?
Great companies are made up of great people who align with a vision behind a talented leader. They have a strategic plan, which they know how to execute. They never try to tackle their problems piecemeal. Instead, their ideas and strategies are brought together under one umbrella into a cohesive plan. Each individual process is carefully studied for its potential to return positive results and its effect on the other strategies.
Interestingly, the first stop when looking at employee turnover is often an examination of employee wages. If we only paid more money, we could get and keep more operators. It’s an alluring argument but it’s dead wrong. Our research shows that while some operators leave the industry because of pay, they are in the minority. The majority churn between companies who all pay about the same amount you do. So don’t fool yourself into thinking that a bump in wages is your best solution. It isn’t.
You need a plan.
You need a plan that everyone can get behind. And, it can’t just be a hodgepodge of ideas. It must be a unified approach of several synergistic processes that collectively eliminate the 192 reasons employees leave.
Start the Journey
There are hundreds of good transit/paratransit companies and agencies, but only a few great ones. The great ones have one thing in common: a relentless commitment to attract, hire and retain great employees. Employee retention is simply part of their DNA. It’s a key element of their strategic plan and overtly supported by the daily actions of the senior leaders.
Retention must be a key element of your strategic plan.
Retention is a key metric for everyone: recruiters, dispatchers, safety, payroll, even sales. Results are measured daily and posted for everyone to see. Compensation and bonuses are based, in part, on employee retention. The loss of a single good employee is a big damn deal and gets a lot of attention and discussion.
So how do you start the journey? If you’re good and really want to be great, it begins with a fanfare. A campaign. An event. However, make no mistake about it, it’s a long slog to greatness. It requires undying fire in the belly, a significant commitment of time and energy, persistence and championship execution. A momentary program or event won’t cut it. Most of all, it begins with an appreciation for your people.
You need a plan and it should begin with a launch campaign. For purposes of getting started, it can be a program with a catchy name. Let’s call our example Operation Retention Reinvention. Once Operation Retention Reinvention begins, it needs a lot of visibility. It needs an internal marketing blitz with vocal and visual support from above.
But the kick-off is the easy part. The real work begins when time has eroded the message and employees begin to drift. You can’t allow that to happen, or your entire initiative evaporates like the flavor of the month. You have to keep stoking the fire with new ideas, persistent follow up and pervasive conversation.
People do what their boss inspects.
Most importantly, you have to be demanding. People typically do what their boss inspects, but not necessarily what their boss expects. That means, you need to establish the expectation that employee retention is really, really important. And then, take an active role in posting the daily results. Follow up with fierce conversations regarding any defection of a desirable employee.
Good really is the enemy of great. It’s fairly easy to be good. It’s acceptable to be good. Everyone likes the good guys. However, real happiness comes from being great. It isn’t easy, but for a select few, it’s well worth the effort.
Great companies attract, hire, nurture and retain great people. They build cohesive teams around a shared vision. They reliably execute dozens of integrated processes under a single cohesive plan to achieve greatness. They focus on their people processes, especially: recruiting, selection and hiring, orientation, education and training, performance support and leadership.
Great transit/paratransit companies have great employees. Employees who stay for years, not months. Employees who show up on time, looking sharp and ready to work. Employees with a can do attitude. Employees who obey the laws and regulations and drive defensively. Employees who understand that their paycheck comes from the customer. Employees who care about their passengers and go the extra mile to help those who need it.
Plugging the turnover leaks allows you to be more selective, which helps you get better and better.
Plugging the turnover leaks in your organization is the first step towards becoming a great transit/paratransit company. It allows you to be more selective with each new hire. And, that ever-increasing selectivity leads to better and better job performance across the board. When you become the employer of choice, everything gets better.
The process of becoming a great transit/paratransit company provides great rewards. It’s a journey well worth taking. Voluntary turnover is a curable form of cancer. Let it eat away at your competition while you become great.
The Transit and Paratransit Safety Company is the leading industry expert in talent management systems and people processes for the transit/paratransit industry. The Transit and Paratransit Safety Company conducts organizational analyses, provides expertise and develops custom selection, orientation, retention, education, training and support systems that result in world class performance among America’s premier service providers.
For more information on this white paper, contact the author, Mark G. Gardner, at firstname.lastname@example.org.